Marijuana mood swing
Tokers say weed works wonders, but science divided on pot for the blues By PAUL TEREFENKO
THINKS NOT GOING WELL? Bummed? Living life in an endless D minor? There's therapy, of course, and a whole pharmacopoeia of mood changers ready to pump your serotonin levels. Or there's marijuana. Maybe.
Two months ago, the International Cannabinoid Research Society (ICRS) held its annual huddle in Budapest, Hungary, where participants reviewed, among other items, the latest studies on pot's effect on mood.
A quick perusal of the conference agenda, however, gives an idea of the yawning gap that now exists between what scientists are able to prove and what tokers are experiencing. For some years, many smokers have claimed reefer as a tonic for funk, posing the possibility that even more are self-treating for depression without even knowing it. And now some therapists are prescribing pot as an alternative to pharma products, with their scary side effects.
But recent studies are contradictory. Some conclude that the green worsens the blues, while others are more hopeful. Last year, for example, a team headed by Dr. Xia Zhang at the U. of Saskatchewan discovered that a synthetic version of the cannabinoid compound found in pot reduces depression in lab rats.
With the profit motive in full force, increasing pharma bucks are now being spent on the pot-mood equation, and we may at last have an answer. Does pot trump Prozac? It depends. One enthusiastic observer is Umar Syed, vice-president of scientific and strategic affairs at Cannasat, a firm hoping to bring cannabis-based pharmaceuticals to market and an attendee of July's ICRS meet. "There's decent scientific evidence that marijuana works for depression," he says.
He points out that back in the 80s, scientists located two cannabinoid receptors in the brain: CB1 and CB2. CB1, in particular, works with THC to alleviate depression, "though the exact mechanism is unknown."
It's no wonder there are so many reports of successful self-medication, he says, because although there up to 60 active ingredients in cannabis, most North American plants have been bred for the high and contain 4 to 8 per cent THC, a substance known to raise depression-easing serotonin levels in the brain. But not everyone is convinced it's THC that makes the difference. Researcher Richard Musty, executive director of the ICRS and a University of Vermont professor emeritus, believes it's cannabidiol (CBD), a non-psychoactive component of the marijuana plant, and not THC, that shows the most promise.
"This is kind of a confusing area right now. It's going to take more time," he cautions. Musty, with others, conducted studies of rats and concluded that CBD has therapeutic potential. He also monitored patients using CBD, and found that two out of five showed improvement.
But he doesn't recommend trying to get your CBD fix from a reefer, because "there's just nothing out there," says Musty, referring to the low CBD content in Canadian pot. And the kicker: when he ran a depression on animals using THC, "it actually made the animals worse," he says.
Dr. Richard Deyo, a professor of psychiatry at Winona State U. in Minnesota, agrees that while there are positive results from components in marijuana, it's not time to roll a J. "Cannabis itself causes depression in some people and seems to alleviate it in others," says Deyo, who presented a paper at the ICRS conference. "There are too many cannabinoids in it, and it's not stable. It can produce one effect today and one effect tomorrow. That's the danger."
Deyo, whose research is funded by drug companies, claims many factors can affect marijuana's effects, including a smoker's age, gender and mental state. He emphasizes that the chemistry of marijuana differs greatly according to the climate in which the plant is grown, making consistent research results tricky.
This, in fact, seems to be the major hurdle of pot studies today. With prohibition the law of the land in North America, researchers have trouble experimenting with the many plant varieties. "Until we have a [conducive] legal environment, you're not going to see any good tests," says Cannabis Culture magazine publisher Marc Emery, who points out that more than 500 different kinds of seeds are available. "The modern medical world is all about dosage ranges that are quantified. Cannabis doesn't work that way; you take it until it works," he says.
While clinical reports are smoky, things certainly look a lot different on the front lines. Here, an empiricism of a different kind is at work: what patients report works for them.
At the Toronto Compassion Centre, Jim Brydges has been dispensing pot for nine years, and while he has no fancy science to describe how it works, he says he's had repeated success treating depressed clients with the leafy green. His technique is mix-and-match; he uses different plants on different people, combining various strains of pot and keeping at it until the client reports feeling better.
"A cannabis-indica-based product we know as M-39, for example, is traditionally known to take away enxiety and relax the person using it," says Brydges.
In California, the only U.S. state that allows doctors to prescribe marijuana for mental illness, there are similar reports. "There's a lot of anecdotal research recorded," says Allen St. Pierre, exec director of the Washington-based National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws. "About 35 per cent of people who go to the dispensaries indicate they're taking cannabis in conjunction with, but more often as a substitute for, everything from attention deficit disorder drugs to very powerful anti-depression and anti-psychotic meds."
This positive experience mirrors that of more scholarly med pot specialist Dr. Lester Grinspoon, associate professor emeritus of psychiatry at Harvard Medical School and author of several landmark books.
Grinspoon points out that no double blind studies had been done on lithium way back when he became the first to prescribe it for bipolar disorder. So he can't see why it shouldn't be acceptable for his patients, many of whom have been helped by pot, to have legal access to it. Why, he seems to ask, don't patient reports count?
His website documenting hundreds of users' positive experiences opens with a quote by native American poet Simon Ortiz: "There are no truths, only stories."
"Government propaganda notwithstanding, marijuana is much less toxic than anything we as psychiatrists have to offer," says Grinspoon. "Some patients find it more useful than Prozac for low-grade depression."
05:25 Hrs. Lektura tronowa. "Polityka" (http://www.polityka.pl/).
05:50 Hrs. Wskakuje na wage APSCO. 87 kg.
06:30 Hrs. Nie wyciagajcie Tytanika. Tam ciagle gra muzyka, a oni w tancu snia - unosi sie w Polskim Radiu Toronto na fali 1320 AM. Na dworze jasno. Spiew ptakow. 8-stopniowo. Bialy przezroczysty polksiezyc na niebie. W dzienniku: Przyczyna pozaru w Kamieniu Pomorskim bedzie znana za kilka dni. Caritas (http://www.caritas.pl/) pomaga poszkodowanym w pozarze. Lukasz Kaminski w IPN. Jeszcze zostalo 2 tygodnie do zlozenia PIT-ow. Do konca kwietnia. Rosyjsko-niemiecki gazociag polnocy zagrozeniem dla Finlandii?
ESSO, Shell, Canadian Tire, Petro-Canada biora za litr paliwa $0.84.2.
Wstajace slonce odbija sie w lusterkach i z przodu w oknach wiezowcow.
Czestuje sie gazetami ze skrzynek: "24 hours" z "North Korea restarts nuclear program" na okladce + "Metro" (www.metronews.ca) z "Sacrifice in vain? Relative of soldier killed in Afghanistan speaks out" na okladce.
15:13 Hrs. "Living a life of the dreamer" - unosi sie w CBC RADIO 1 na fali 99.1 FM gdy wracam z pracy do domu. Na dworze slonecznie. 14-stopniowo. Szyba uchylona.
W domu wyjmuje ze skrzynki na listy kartke swiateczna od Ireny & Wojtka z Woodstock + ulotke Axis Communications' Academy 2009 Advanced Training Modules (http://www.axis.com/us/academy).
Na kopercie od Wojtka stoi: JESUS CHRIST IS TRULY RISEN ALLELUJA! + "Life is the only choice". Wewnatrz koperty kartka kolorowa "Radosnych Swiat" z koszyczkiem pisanek i 2 kurczaczkami. Napis:
Radosnego Alleluja!!! W uroczysty dzien Zmartwychwstania Pana Niech ON obdarzy Was Pokojem serca i radoscia Na kazdy dzien
tego szczerze zyczy Irena & Wojciech S from Woodstock.
Dziekuje Wam przyjaciele. Takze Wam zyczymy zdrowia i radosci ze Zmartwychwstania Panskiego. Niech Bog ma Was w swojej opiece!
Woodstock jest ostatnio popularny w mediach z powodu zaginiecia dziecka w tym miescie. Jest to 37 tys. miasteczko polozone 140 km. od Toronto.
No comments:
Post a Comment